Reviews & Articles

CLOSED

DUE TO

COLONIALISM,

ELITISM, AND A PRIVATE

DINNER

Spike art magazine chose these words as a sub-title for its ‘Museum’ (Spring, 2023) issue, and printed it on a T-shirt.

It’s no doubt inspired by one of the pioneers of text-as-art, the American artist Barbara Kruger, whose words critique the world, especially of power and consumerism. Her epigram, “I shop therefore I am” is probably the best known; similar pithy text has been seen worldwide in museums, on advertising billboards, and with intentional irony, on tote bags. Following her lead, this style of tongue-in-cheek product is a staple for edgy art world merchandise - always termed “merch” as if it’s an attitude, rather than just a product.

Spike is a themed quarterly English-language print magazine with a strong digital presence based in Vienna and Berlin. Its articles cover a range of art topics, accompanied by bright provocative photography, and supported by online articles on fashion, food, cinema, music, design, architecture and urbanism. The key art centres of London, New York, Paris are featured, and the not so obvious, such as Turin in Italy.

It’s a worldly art magazine, so it’s no surprise that Kaitlin Chan, Hong Kong cartoonist and director of Empty Gallery in Tin Wan near Aberdeen, was asked to give her choices for the magazine’s ‘Tops and Flops 2025’ year round-up - IN: “The Darkest Hour at 3am”, exhibition at Current Plans, Hong Kong / IN: Minor Black Figures, novel by Brandon Taylor / OUT: Materialists, film by Celine Song / OUT: Lububu birthday cakes.

Her selection reflects the Spike spirit – a magazine that is variously funny, nerdy, erudite, pretentious, fashionable and always informative of trends and what young people are thinking or doing. This attitude reflects a healthy aspect of the art world: adopting the eclectic, creative and worldly energy of artists. Whereas, too often it is the hype of the art marketplace that gets the mainstream media’s attention: worldwide art auction prices, collectors’ fundraisers, the latest hot artists, big-name gallery gossip, expensive museum acquisitions or daring burglaries, or, March’s one-week buzz around Hong Kong’s Art Basel.

For the other fifty-one weeks of the year, Hong Kong’s artists quietly do their art in studios or other spaces. They organise themselves or join exhibitions with museums, galleries, or independent art spaces throughout the year – invited by curators or gallery owners. The city also regularly sees the work of significant artists from around the world. Arts writers and critics write about what they see and experience, online or in print magazines and newspapers. Art teachers and their students offer experimentation and assessment when making art. While art historians and museums contribute necessary scholarship and academic enquiry. This art ecology is replicated in any mature city around the world, Hong Kong included.

In essence, it is not dissimilar to the workings of any industry or commercial activity that relies on layers of learning, research, expertise, manufacturing, marketing and sales to prosper and continue. The government’s interest in the “creative industries” and “cultural tourism” acknowledges its niche economic importance for Hong Kong.

The origins of Hong Kong’s art infrastructure began slowly, after 1949 as waves of people arrived in the city at the end of China’s civil war. A regular flow of Chinese antiquities, including rare ceramics, ink paintings and other traditional art or literati objects also arrived in Hong Kong – legitimately or illegally – over the following years from the mainland. Hong Kong’s free port status, minimal taxes, open entry and exit of goods, generally unsupervised money flow, and a no questions asked environment were advantages quickly recognised by the antique market.

Amid Hong Kong’s booming post-war economy, astute buyers began building traditional Chinese art collections – many of international importance. By the 1970s Hollywood Road antique dealers were well-established and international auction houses consolidated the secondary market with their seasonal auctions of important ceramics and ink paintings.

Benefiting from its geographical location with careful purchases and collector donations, the Hong Kong Museum of Art and The Chinese University of Hong Kong’s Museum now have world-class collections of traditional Chinese art and regularly feature superb exhibitions. The Palace Museum at West Kowloon and the Hong Kong Heritage Discovery Centre in Kowloon Park both now mount excellent temporary traditional art and archaeological exhibitions working closely with mainland museums.

By the 1980s, Hong Kong’s traditional art market was firmly in place and contemporary galleries began opening, including Galerie de Monde (now known as gdm), Hanart TZ Gallery and Alisan Fine Art; all still going strong. Slowly, auction houses also began offering contemporary art and other collectibles (wine, handbags etc). Chinese domestic art collectors started visited Hong Kong after the mainland’s economy opened in 1992 and travel was liberalised to Hong Kong in the 2000s. Tapping this new clientele and recognising the city’s advantageous business atmosphere, large international commercial galleries, including David Zwirner, White Cube, Hauser & Wirth and Gagosian all opened galleries, joining Hong Kong galleries with solid and diverse gallery programmes, such as Blindspot Gallery, Kiang Malingue, Rossi & Rossi, Gallery Exit, de Sarthe Gallery and Empty Gallery.

Art Basel acquired the former Hong Kong Art Fair in 2014 to initiate its presence in Asia. Its current global business plan, spearheaded by new majority owner James Murdoch, son of Rupert, is for each of the five current Art Basel art fairs to operate in different physical time-zones around the world. Murdoch is following the Formula One car racing approach: strategically operate races on all continents for a global audience reach. Inevitably, each fair will increasingly cater to a local and regional audience; for example, the new Art Basel Qatar will have a Middle East focus; Art Basel Miami Beach will cater for a South American clientele and Art Basel Hong Kong will appeal to mainland and other Asian art collectors and galleries.

The type of private donor-funded museum or art space that Spike is poking fun at on its T-shirt doesn’t quite exist in Hong Kong, although Parasite and the Asia Art Archive have yearly fundraising dinners. Our low personal income tax precludes any incentive to make cash donations to a museum. The Leisure & Cultural Service Department Museums - including the Hong Kong Museum of Art, university museums, the Palace Museum, M+ and Tai Kwun Contemporary, are either mostly government-funded or receive funds through the Hong Kong Jockey Club Charity Trust (e.g. public losses from gambling). This also explains why Hong Kong has few private museums – there are few tax planning or philanthropic incentives to fund a museum.

However, one example does stand out. The former Nan Fung Textiles factory in Tsuen Wan is one building in a complex of factories built after the 1950s that made Nan Fung the world’s biggest textile manufacturer by the 1960s. In honour of that legacy, the old factory has been expertly preserved and converted as the Centre for Heritage, Art and Textile, or Mills6/CHAT. CHAT’s excellent heritage textile and manufacturing displays, art gallery and contemporary exhibitions are funded by on-site rental income, Nan Fung - now a property developer, and through the D.C. Chen Foundation, the family foundation of the company’s founder.

CHAT's small team of curators organise both contemporary and historical displays that revolve around textiles and the processes of its manufacture. In  one small but exquisite historical exhibition around Hong Kong textile heritage. contemporary exhibitions that   

The readers of Spike would also be impressed by the building’s organic coffee outlets, funky design shops, rooftop murals and veggie garden, and a dog-friendly venue where hundreds of dogs and their owners meet on weekends and compare each other in the main hall. 

Tsuen Wan, reached by catching the 930X bus from Tin Hau, through Central, arriving near to CHAT, is the sort of off-beat art and retro neighbourhood that would happily feature in Spike magazine. Spike, of course, is Snoopy’s brother and the inspiration for the magazine – even he, despite living a solitary non-art life in the desert, might like to see other dogs and CHAT’s always stimulating exhibitions.